The result of this is that the states became more united under the Constitution than under the articles. In place of executive and judicial branches, The Articles created an inefficient committee system branching out of Congress.
Some of the weaknesses of these Articles were economic disorganization, lack of central government power, and legislative inefficiencies.
Constitution focused on one basic premise: However, if we look at the Epic of Gilgamesh or the Code of Hammurabi, we find that the earliest civilizations had to provide structure and that evil nature was as much a part of humanity as goodness. The Constitution gave Congress the mandate of making decisions pertaining to conflicts, peace, and engaging in foreign relations.
Without an executive branch the country lacked a clear, decisive leader. Thus, the Federalists really only had the appearance of victory after the Constitutional Convention, not the buy in and acceptance of the policy for decades afterwards.
Feel free to order a custom written paper now. The powers vested on the President and the Congress by the Constitution raised the sovereignty level of the central government in reigning over the citizens and assuring security from an internal or external threat.
Additionally, the Constitution provided for a smooth mechanism of empowering the federal government and thus strengthened the association among all states.
Also, the Constitution provided respective courts with the jurisdiction to solve the disputes arising among different jurisdictions. Get a complete paper today. Most importantly, any amendment to the Articles of Confederation required the ratification by all the states, a measure that virtually eliminated any chance of change.
In terms of trade regulation, the federal government was given the power over trade control at both inter-state and international levels. E The land was sold and the proceeds were used for the benefit of public schools as well as to pay off national debt.
Britain declined to make a commercial treaty or repeal the ancient Navigation Laws. Even when trade between America and Britain occurred as United States population increased, meaning more goods, the estimated market value for American exports to great Britain still remained the same.
In addition, the Congress was given power to raise funds and provide for the army. The Congress took part in significant affairs of the country during the last two years of the Revolution, helped to negotiate treaty of Paris in and produced two monumental pieces of legislation.
They were a model of what a loose Confederation should be.
However, The Articles were insufficient in several important matters. The Constitution completely reversed the distribution of authority, transferring numerous economic powers from the states to Congress. The fourth weakness ensured the demise of the Confederation by making it too difficult to correct the first three.
Despite, success in expansion policies, The Articles of Confederation was a failure in creating a prosperous and efficacious country that could support and defend itself and its people.
However, every level of government exercise huge extent of autonomy having been offered some particular powers that not even the federal government can curtail.
The process of creating the Constitution did not just happen, but was marred by intense debate and numerous proposals of the appropriate version. The first momentous legislation passed by the Congress was The Land Ordinance of The debate remains -- is the cup…… [Read More] Hobbes looked around, and saw a sewer of urban life; poor people struggling, disease, trash, pestilence and believed that without control mankind was nothing more than animalistic.
The weaknesses of the Articles further divided the union and as a result the government was not able to properly handle international crises. In place of executive and judicial branches, The Articles created an inefficient committee system branching out of Congress.
In conclusion, the drafting of the Constitution can be simplified to a transfer of economic power to the national government used to generate secure sources of revenue to get out of debt. Due to the need for better regulation of interstate commerce, a group of fifty-five delegates congregated to form the Constitutional Convention, with the objective of drafting an entirely new constitution.
Instead, it was to assess its expenses and divide those among the states on the basis of the value of land. By the late 18th century it was clear that the United States would not prosper under the Articles of Confederation.
As stated, these provisions stripped the states of the power they retained under the Articles, and bestowed them onto Congress. Additionally, the Constitution gave Congress the mandate of making decisions pertaining to conflicts, peace, and engaging in foreign relations.The Articles had not provided for such power to the central government to control interstate and international trade.
In conclusion, “the Articles of Confederation” had numerous weaknesses that adversely affected the smooth operation of the central government in fulfilling its mandate. Download thesis statement on ARTICLES OF CONFEDERATION vs THE CONSTITUTION in our database or order an original thesis paper that will be written by one of our staff writers and delivered according to the deadline.
Articles of confederation created inwas the first constitution of the United States of America. The Articles of Confederation had served as the agreement between the. We will write a custom essay sample on Articles of Confederation vs.
Constitution specifically for you. for only $ $/page. Order now. Search.
Related Essays. Constitution a Radical Departure from the Articles of Confederation? Why the Articles Of Confederation Failed. Essay: Articles of Confederation As the first written constitution of the United States, the Articles of Confederation created a legislature where each state was represented equally.
Apr 11, · The Articles of Confederation lacked the balance of powers embedded in the future Constitution, and for which the Constitution is renowned. ithout an executive branch in the federal government, and without a federal judiciary, the new nation seemed precariously weak under the Articles.Download